What Are the Differences Between Judicial and Nonjudicial Foreclosures?

What to Know About Foreclosures During the Coronavirus Outbreak

It’s difficult to predict how judicial and nonjudicial foreclosure processes might change in the future as a result of coronavirus. Many courts are closed to non-essential matters because of the COVID-19 emergency and won’t accept certain pleadings, like those related to foreclosures, or conduct hearings about such matters. Also, some county recorder’s offices are closed.

Maybe in upcoming foreclosures, pleadings will always have to be filed electronically rather than at the courthouse. Hearings that used to be held in courtrooms might take place over video, or they might be restricted to essential parties only. Perhaps all sheriff’s sales and trustee’s sales will be conducted online—as some currently are—rather than on the courthouse steps. Exactly how foreclosure procedures in different states will transform due to coronavirus, and whether those changes will be temporary or permanent, is up in the air at this point.

Homeowners can lose their residential properties through one of two methods of foreclosure: judicial foreclosure (a process that involves the court system) and nonjudicial foreclosure (which allows a lender to sell the property without prior approval from a judge). The foreclosure type that your bank chooses will depend on the options afforded by the law of the state where the property is located. In either case, foreclosure law is complicated, which means that hiring a knowledgeable attorney will increase your chances of keeping your home.

 

Judicial Foreclosure

A judicial foreclosure requires the lender to go through the state court system and receive approval from a judge to foreclose on a property. All states allow the lender to foreclose judicially; however, some require this process exclusively. For instance, in New York and Ohio, foreclosures are judicial.

How a Judicial Foreclosure Begins

The lender starts the process by filing a lawsuit with the court. In the lender’s opening pleading, often called a “complaint” or a “petition,” the lender asks the court for the right to sell the home and apply the proceeds from the sale to the debt.

If state law allows for it, the complaint might also ask the court to grant a deficiency judgment if selling the property won’t fully pay off the debt. If granted, the borrower will remain responsible for the outstanding balance left on the loan after the foreclosure sale. Some states don’t allow deficiency judgments under certain circumstances.

Responding to the Lawsuit

After the lender files the court case, you must file a responsive pleading—such as an answer to the complaint or motion to dismiss the case—with the court generally within 30 or fewer days. If you don’t respond, the lender will ask the court for a default judgment and will automatically be declared the winner.

Your response must be in the format described in the local court rules. For example, you’ll likely need to create a caption at the top of the first page that includes the names of the people and businesses involved in the lawsuit, the name and address of the court, and the case number. If you file an answer, you’ll include responses to each of the claims made by the lender and any defenses you might have, as well.

It’s important to understand that filing an answer isn’t always the best choice. If you have an argument that requires you to file another type of pleading to preserve your rights, filing an incorrect response might cause you to lose an important right. For instance, a lender must comply with the law before a court has “jurisdiction” (authority) to hear a case. If the lender made a mistake, like by failing to properly serve you with the lawsuit, you can dispute the court’s jurisdiction by filing a motion to dismiss. If you win, the lender must start over. If, however, you file an answer, you are “stipulating,” or agreeing, that the court has the right to hear the matter and the case moves forward. Bottom-line, litigation is tricky stuff and most people fare better by getting help from a lawyer.

The lawsuit will then likely move to the discovery stage—the stage that allows both sides learn about evidence in the other’s possession. Both you and the lender will be able to obtain information using discovery tools, such as:

  • written interrogatories (questions about case-related facts that the other side must answer in writing)
  • requests for the production of documents (a demand requiring the other party to turn over specified documents)
  • depositions (the other side testifies under oath in front of a court reporter), and
  • property inspections (one side views real estate or property, such as a car, that’s in the other side’s possession).

As a result of what it learns during discovery, or perhaps before, the lender might file a “summary judgment” motion, asking the judge to decide the entire matter without a trial. The lender will present its arguments and evidence in the motion. You have the right to oppose the motion by submitting your arguments and evidence, as well. If the court finds that you don’t have evidence that can support a defense, the lender will win the motion, obtain a judgment, and be free to proceed with a foreclosure sale. If the judge denies the lender’s motion, the court will allow the case to proceed to trial.

Nonjudicial Foreclosures

To complete a nonjudicial foreclosure, the lender follows the steps outlined in state law. About half of the states allow nonjudicial foreclosures, including California, Nevada, and Arizona. Although the exact steps vary from state to state, the lender might have to:

  • send you a notice of default (a notice that you’re behind on your payments)
  • record the notice of default in the county records, and
  • send you a notice of sale, letting you know the sale date of your home.

Some states allow the lender to send just a notice of sale, a combined notice of default and sale, or permit notification by publishing a notice in the newspaper and posting it somewhere on the property or somewhere public. You might face a deficiency judgment lawsuit following a nonjudicial foreclosure, depending on state law. To fight a nonjudicial foreclosure, you, or your attorney, will have to file a lawsuit on your behalf, and then the case will generally proceed in the same manner as a judicial foreclosure

How Long Will the Foreclosure Process Take?

The length of the foreclosure process depends on the type of foreclosure and the laws in your state. For example, once officially started, nonjudicial foreclosure can happen pretty quickly because there is no court action—though it varies by state. Give us a call to understand more about Florida’s process. (Learn about the federal law that delays the start of most foreclosures for 120 days.)

Judicial foreclosures usually last longer—not always—because a court must sign off on the foreclosure. But if you fail to file a response to a complaint and the lender obtains a default judgment against you, the case could be over in as little as a month. That’s not usually what happens, though. If you respond in a timely manner, court backlogs and judges’ burdened schedules can result in a wait of six months to several years before your foreclosure action goes to trial. New York and New Jersey are examples of places known for their lengthy foreclosure process.

Questions for Your Attorney

  1. How much time do I have to respond to a foreclosure lawsuit in my state?
  2. If I respond to a foreclosure lawsuit, but I don’t have a defense, will I have to pay my lender’s attorneys’ fees?
  3. Does my state give a bank the right to get a deficiency judgment against me?

If you have been served with foreclosure, give us a call at 561.838.9595 or email us at info@jamesnbrownpa.com. We can represent you to defend your foreclosure and discuss exit strategies such as loan modification, sale, short sale or deed in lieu of foreclosure.